Does Peat Moss Make Soil Acidic? A pH Discussion

I’d been gardening for about 3 years before I ever heard the term peat moss.

I thought it was a literal moss, so I was shocked to see what looked like dirt when I opened the package.

Peat moss, however, is NOT dirt—and using it like dirt can actually harm some plants.

Let’s chat about it!

Understanding Peat Moss

Peat moss is an organic material derived from decomposed sphagnum moss and other organic materials found in peat bogs.

These bogs are formed over hundreds (to potentially thousands) of years and act as effective carbon dioxide sinks, absorbing significant amounts of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere.

As you read about this common soil amendment, you may hear two terms:

• sphagnum
• sphagnum peat moss

Sphagnum is the living moss found on the surface of bogs, while sphagnum peat moss is the decomposed material found beneath the surface.

Peat moss is valued as a soil amendment for its excellent water retention properties, sterile nature, and ability to improve soil aeration.

Plus, the fact that peat moss adds organic matter to the soil—especially clay soils that really need it—is a benefit in and of itself.

However, peat moss harvesting is a matter of debate due to its non-renewable nature. Extracting peat moss from bogs leads to the release of stored carbon dioxide, and it can damage wetland ecosystems and harm their unique flora and fauna.

In the United States, peat moss can be purchased in compressed bales, but it can be relatively expensive compared to other soil amendments.

With the growing awareness of the environmental disadvantages and overall environmental concerns of peat moss, gardeners often seek out peat moss alternatives for their vegetable garden.

The most common are:

• coconut coir
• compost
• aged bark

Peat Moss and Soil pH Levels

Peat moss is naturally acidic, so adding peat moss to already acidic soil may further lower its pH.

In case you need a refresher on acidity …

The pH scale ranges from 0 to 14, with 7 being neutral. A pH level below 7 is considered acidic, while a pH above 7 is alkaline.

Most plants prefer a soil pH between 6.0 and 7.0, although some plants—such as azaleas, rhododendrons, and blueberries—thrive in more acidic soil. On the other hand, plants like lilacs and clematis prefer a more alkaline soil.

When you mix peat moss into your soil, the pH level may decrease, making it more acidic. This can be beneficial for acid-loving plants, but it’s important to monitor the soil’s pH levels to ensure they stay within the ideal range for the plants you’re growing.

You can use a pH meter or a simple soil pH test kit to measure the acidity or alkalinity of your soil:

Keep in mind that adjusting soil pH levels is a gradual process that may take several months or even years. It’s essential to test your soil’s pH and make adjustments as needed.

Role of Peat Moss in Gardening As a Soil Amendment

When it comes to enhancing your garden soil, peat moss can be a valuable addition.

As a soil amendment, it can improve the overall structure, aeration, and water retention of your soil, creating a more favorable environment for your plants.

In particular, for acid-loving plants such as blueberries, azaleas, and rhododendrons, peat moss can provide the ideal acidity levels they require.

Its unique quality of retaining moisture makes it an exceptional choice for container-grown plants or when transplanting seedlings to allow for better hydration and growth.

Gardeners frequently use peat moss as an effective compost component or to create soilless potting mixes. By mixing it with other elements, such as vermiculite or perlite, you can significantly improve the soil’s airiness, promoting root growth, and providing adequate drainage.

For those with challenging clay soil, incorporating peat moss can loosen the compacted structure, enhancing the soil’s drainage capacity while still maintaining appropriate moisture levels.

This improvement to the soil structure aids in the healthy growth of flowers, shrubs, and trees.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Using Peat Moss

There’s two sides to every story, right? Let’s discuss the pros and cons of using peat moss.

First and foremost, peat moss provides excellent aeration and drainage to your soil, ensuring your plants receive adequate oxygen and avoid becoming waterlogged.

As an organic amendment, peat moss also helps to retain water, keeping your plants hydrated.

This moisture retention capability is particularly useful in dry or sandy soils.

In addition to its water retention properties, peat moss is known for its low nutrient content. While that may seem counterintuitive, it can be beneficial for plants that thrive in acidic environments.

Peat moss can effectively lower the pH of your soil, making it more favorable for acid-loving plants like blueberries or azaleas.

Furthermore, peat moss is typically free of weed seeds and pathogens. Adding peat moss to your soil can help reduce the risk of introducing unwanted plants or diseases into your garden.

Its sterile nature is also ideal for starting seeds indoors.

On the other hand, since peat moss is low in nutrients, it’s not an adequate growth medium for plants beyond the seedling stage.

While excellent for water retention, peat moss can occasionally retain too much water, leading to a soggy soil environment unsuitable for some plants.

You need to be particularly careful not to over-water when working with peat moss.

---

---

Alternatives to Peat Moss in Gardening

When looking for an alternative to peat moss in your garden, there are a variety of options you can consider. Some of these alternatives are more environmentally friendly and offer unique benefits to your soil and plants.

Coconut Coir: This is a popular alternative to peat moss. It’s made from the fibers between the shell and outer covering of coconuts. Similar to peat moss, coconut coir can improve soil structure, yet it’s more sustainable. You can use it in soilless potting mixes, seed starting, and as a soil conditioner.

Bark and Pine Bark: Bark products, particularly pine bark, can be used instead of peat moss to improve soil structure and drainage. Bark is often used in potting soils and mixes. You can also use ground or shredded bark as mulch to help suppress weeds, conserve moisture, and insulate plant roots.

Pine Needles and Oak Leaves: Adding organic materials like pine needles and oak leaves to your soil can help alter its acidity and mineral content. While peat moss can make soil more acidic, pine needles and oak leaves can have a similar effect in varying degrees, depending on the decomposition rate. These options also help add nutrients to your soil as they break down.

Lime and Elemental Sulfur: Lime is used to raise the pH of your soil, making it less acidic, while elemental sulfur lowers the soil pH, making it more acidic.

Soilless Potting Mixes: Consider using a soilless potting mix for starting seeds and growing container plants. Soilless potting mixes contain a combination of coconut coir, bark, perlite, and other lightweight materials, offering excellent drainage and aeration.

Vinegar: While it may not be a long-term solution, you can use vinegar in small amounts to temporarily adjust your soil’s acidity. Mixing a small amount of vinegar with water and applying it to your soil should be done with caution, as excessive use can harm your plants.

Keep in mind that the specific alternative you choose will depend on your gardening needs and the plants you are cultivating.

Peat Moss and Its Effect on Specific Plants

We’ve mentioned a few already in this post, but peat moss is best used with acid-loving plants:

• blueberries
• rhododendrons
• azaleas
• holly
• cranberries
• currants

By lowering the pH of alkaline soils, peat moss allows these plants to better absorb essential nutrients, preventing deficiencies. For instance, iron and aluminum sulfate are two crucial nutrients for acid-loving plants, and peat moss ensures that they remain available for absorption.

However, it’s important to note that not all plants prefer acidic soil. There are many vegetables and fruits that require a more neutral or slightly alkaline soil environment for proper growth. For such plants, adding peat moss can potentially hinder their development.

Some plants you do NOT want to use peat moss with include:

• asparagus
• beets
• garlic

Always keep your plants’ individual needs in mind when considering any amendments to your garden soil.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does peat moss affect soil acidity?

Peat moss can indeed affect the soil acidity. It is a slightly acidic organic material with a pH level of around 4.0 to 4.5. When you add peat moss to your soil, it can lower the pH, making the soil more acidic.

What is the pH level of Canadian Sphagnum Peat Moss?

Canadian Sphagnum Peat Moss has a pH level in the range of 4.0 to 4.5, making it slightly acidic. This characteristic is beneficial for improving soil conditions and nutrient availability for acid-loving plants, as previously mentioned.

How can peat moss be made less acidic?

If you need to make peat moss less acidic, you can mix it with a more alkaline material like garden lime or dolomitic limestone. This will help neutralize the acidity and raise the pH level. Make sure to start with small amounts and gradually increase if needed, while monitoring your soil’s pH levels to ensure optimal conditions for your specific plants.

How much peat moss should be added to soil?

The amount of peat moss to add to your soil depends on your desired outcome and the current soil conditions. Generally, a ratio of 10% to 40% peat moss mixed with your existing soil can be suitable, with 30% often being ideal for most cases. However, it’s essential to consider your plants’ specific needs and adjust the mix accordingly.